Your best therapist has a line out the door and a stack of notes she never finishes.
You tell yourself the patients love her and it isn’t worth the conversation.
If you run a physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech, or mental health practice, you know who I mean.
How this story came up with two of my clients
I was working with two clients who co-own a practice, and we were writing down their values.
For each value, we wrote what it means and then an example of how it shows up day to day. They had defined integrity as doing what you say you’re going to do and owning it when you don’t.
I shared an example from my own practice.
My best therapist and 400 notes
She was my best therapist if you looked at it one way. People loved her. There was a line out the door, and I always heard rave reviews about her.
She never did her notes.
Our system tied billing to the notes, which meant we couldn’t bill for her visits. We’re not talking about ten or twenty. By the time I let her go, she had 400 outstanding notes at a hundred dollars a pop.
That is forty thousand dollars, and closer to sixty thousand in today’s money.
Payers set deadlines for filing claims, and Medicare’s is one calendar year from the date of service, with no appeal rights for a claim denied as late. Past those deadlines, unfinished notes turn into lost revenue. I lost about half of that money.
She told me many times, “Yep, I’ll go ahead and do it.” No matter what I said or what I did, we did not share that value.
The way I defined integrity at my practice was doing what you say you’re going to do. By that measure she fell short, and I’m sure plenty of people would describe her differently.
I couldn’t stay with that. Letting her stay would have shown everyone around her that the standards apply to everyone except her.
That was not easy.
How it ended
My business grew after she left. I never thought I could replace the number of patients she was seeing, and on paper she was doing great.
I had a coach then, and believe me, I did not think of the next part myself. I threw her a happy hour. Her parents came, and I had never met them.
I had basically fired her, and I framed it as her moving on to another place after two great years. We celebrated, and everyone came.
I was furious about the money. I also had a choice, because we always control our attitude and how we respond.
She took about half her patients with her. I was okay with that, because I couldn’t stop her. It was growth for me and for the business, and it reinforced the values we were talking about.
Production makes it easy to look away
Harvard Business School researchers who studied about 50,000 workers found that people who were later fired for violating company policy tended to out-produce their peers, which helps explain why managers keep them as long as they do.
Her notes were a smaller version of the same pattern. Strong production makes it easy to look away, and the rest of your team sees you doing it.
Three steps for handling a top producer who ignores your standards
A standard has to be something people can see before you can hold anyone to it.
Write the standard as something people can see
Values are behaviors. They are how we show up.
Mine was integrity, which meant doing what you say you’re going to do. An example is committing to your notes on time and then doing them.
Only 19 percent of employees strongly agree their manager explains how the organization’s cultural values influence their work, according to Gallup. Write the value, a short description, and one example like the notes.
Tell the person, then let them choose
Say the standard out loud, show where it is being missed, and ask what they will do.
I think of it as being clear about what we’re about and letting the person choose whether they want to be part of it. If the answer is yes and nothing changes, you already know the next step.
Settle the open work and plan the exit
Agree on what gets finished before the last day. Filing deadlines don’t move, and I lost about half the money on those notes.
Then decide how you want the exit to look. Mine was a party. Expect some patients to follow her, and let that be fine.
Write down the standard your best producer misses
Think about your best producer.
Write down the one standard they miss that everyone else meets. Once it’s on paper, you have what you need for the conversation you’ve been putting off.
Have a practice story worth sharing?

We’re recording more Freedom By Design episodes, and I’d like to hear from PT, OT, SLP, and mental health practice owners who have grown to multiple locations or sold their practice.
Someone out there is stuck where you used to be, and hearing how you got through it could help.
The form takes a couple of minutes:
————————————————————-
Are you ready for a coach? Join the hundreds of physical therapy owners who are building the practice of their dreams with the support, guidance and direction of a Practice Freedom U Coach. Take the first step towards creating a business that sets you free by scheduling a Discovery Call